Analog Birthday: Matt on Flashpoint #1-3 (1999 Limited Series)

October 18, 2017

For my birthday a few weeks back, I had a couple of beers and then went longbox diving for random things I vaguely remember that are not available digitally, not least because I could then write posts about them here. This is one of those things.

THE BOOK:  Flashpoint #1-3, a limited series published by DC comics in 1999-2000 under the Elseworlds banner. This book was was either so good or so unmemorable that DC has gone on to reuse the title in both print and TV without ever seeming to remember that they’d already used it once! (Seriously: the writer’s entry on the DC Comics website links to the first three issues of the much-later Geoff Johns series instead of the actual book.)

THE CREATORS: Written by Pat McGreal, art by Norm Breyfogle, colors by Noelle Giddings, letters by Rick Parker.

THE CONCEPT: The high-concept backstory is the key here: In an alternate timeline of the DC Universe, Silver Age Flash Barry Allen is shot in the spine while saving John F. Kennedy from the assassination attempt in Dallas. Paralyzed from the neck down, Allen’s only remaining power is his super-speed brain. The world spins off from there.


The actual plot of the story takes place in 1999. Allen’s super-science programs uncover an artifact on Mars. Contact with the artifact throws Allen’s nephew, Wally West (without superspeed, since Allen’s time as the Flash ended before Wally got his powers), into a coma and ultimately kills him. A private eye named Ralph Dibny (also powerless, because ???) is hired by mysterious parties to investigate. The Martian Manhunter and Vandal Savage show up. A clone of Wally West gets Flash powers. Then there’s a semi-incomprehensible ending.

DC’s Elseworlds books–the fancy 1990’s branding for these alternate takes on their characters, the kind of stuff that used to be called “imaginary stories” until Alan Moore sucked all the joy and fun out of that term–had tended to be pricey prestige format editions. This was (according to a note in the text page of the final issue) the imprint’s first foray into a limited series, which I suppose would let buyers consider the book while only investing three bucks instead of six or eight or whatever prestige format books cost by this point.

It’s a sensible plan, doubly so because the best part of any Elseworlds story is almost always the setup–seeing familiar characters branch off is fun; once they’ve branched, you’re often left just reading a weirdly off-brand superhero story filled with pointless easter eggs to remind you that it’s published by the actual rights-holder of the IP. Which is pretty much the case here!


  • The high concept, for sure. It does a good job of starting from a familiar place, adding a totally comprehensible tweak, and launching an entertaining plot of it. There are some particularly clever elements–the actual shot that paralyzes Allen comes out of nowhere, travelling at near-lightspeed, and is this timeline’s “magic bullet” of the Kennedy assassination attempt.
  • I’m a mark for Norm Breyfogle’s art, so that counts as a plus for me. I’m not sure it always captures what I want from a Flash story–Breyfogle, to me, excels at shadows, at sudden frozen moments, at cartoonish exaggeration, so this story isn’t always playing to his strengths. When it does, though–a hi-tech robbery sequence; the flashback to the Kennedy assassination (attempt); the designs (and establishing shots) for Barry Allen’s orbiting research facility and Vandal Savage’s thrustingly phallic headquarters–it’s a total delight.
  • There are a couple of text pieces about the creation of the series that are a fun look into the process of developing a standalone miniseries in the late-nineties. They’re classic “interesting if that’s the kind of thing that interests you” material.
  • Really, the first two issues are pretty solid, if I’m being honest. McGreal builds well off of his initial setup, and at a bare minimum it’s a competently told, solidly executed superhero story that takes me into the last issue wanting to see where it goes. Unfortunately….


  • The third issue suffers from classic Elseworld’s syndrome. A defining feature of superhero comics is that they never end; by definition an alternate reality story has to, and usually has to do so pretty rapidly. This creates some contradictory story needs–a disproportionate amount of time spent on setup creates a buildup that very few endings are going to be able to payoff–that this piece in particular really suffers from.
  • It’s also not helped by the fact that the MacGuffin of this plot makes VERY little sense, and degenerates into super-generic “He’s going to use the widget to open a portal to the Fooferaw!” meaninglessness very quickly. McGreal and Breyfogle, to their credit, just about manage to sell the actual climactic moments and the denouement, but man, the final conflict is allllllllll jibber-jabber.
  • How long have we been doing the bit where a mysterious figure is startled by the flame of a man lighting a cigarette, and that mysterious figure turns out to be a DC Universe Martian? At least this long.
  • It’s a fairly minor note, but this story also commits one of my cardinal sins of an alternate reality: the hero has vague, ambiguous dreams of the “real” DC Universe. Why? I dunno. How? I dunno. What’s the point? Beats me, other than, again, to remind you that this isn’t some cheap knockoff from Malibu or Acclaim or whoever–these are REAL DC comics, friend!

SHOULD IT BE ONLINE: Yes. Leaving aside the odd resonance of the title in the modern DC Universe, this is EXACTLY the kind of story that’s worth buying on a 99-cents-per-issue sale. In fact, that’s probably the ONLY way you should consider buying this–it’s solid, and fun if you have affection for any of the characters, creators, or concepts, but it’s also totally disposable.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment on “Analog Birthday: Matt on Flashpoint #1-3 (1999 Limited Series)

  1. Bruce Baugh Oct 18, 2017

    Wow. Now there’s a birthday present for all of us! I have precisely zero memory of this story, and am glad to know of it. Thanks. :)